Five students walk into detention, but only 4 come out. As the details of the events of what happened that fateful day in detention start unraveling, the Bayview Four, portrayed by Marianly Tejada, Annalisa Cochrane, Chibuikem Uche, and Cooper van Grootel, find themselves at the height of everyone’s suspicion, even being dubbed the ‘murder club’ by their peers. Based on the book by Karen M. McManus, the first season of One of Us is Lying ends on a major cliff hanger, with more secrets and lies brewing.

In a discussion with Ashley V. Robinson, the Bayview Four chat what’s to come in season 2 and fan predictions.

“Or we’ll see people chop up the trailer,” Chibuikem Uche says to Popverse. “And they’ll like tell you what the scene is, and I’m like you don’t have enough context to know, but yet somehow they do. I’m like this is impressive.”

Here is our full interview with the cast of One of Us is Lying:

Want more of the Bayview Four? You can watch the New York Comic Con spotlight panel featuring the casthere: