Popverse's top stories of the day

• Dune: Prophecy creators promise to bring the "complexity" and "grand scale" of Frank Herbert's books and Denis Villeneuve's movies to TV
• Marvel's TV head says there's "absolutely" a future for Jon Bernthal's Punisher after his Daredevil: Born Again appearance
• Meet the Grim Reaper of The Walking Dead TV show cast, and what goes into killing someone off in the show

What does an comic book editor do when they lose a writer or artist?

That's the question that was posed to Louise Simonson at Baltimore Comic Con 2024, during a panel called Mutant Mayhem, which celebrated the long history of Marvel's finest supergroup. Simonson, who not only edited the X-books for some time but also co-created X-movie stars Apocalypse and Cable, knew a thing or two about a surprise change in the creative lineup, as she was only too happy to share.

"I had John Byrne leave the X-Men!" she began by saying. And she feels a little bit of that exit had her to blame.

Some context: Louise Simonson joined the Uncanny X-Men editorial team in January of 1980. In March of 1981, artist John Byrne left the Uncanny X-Men book after four years of work, much of which - such as the Dark Phoenix saga - would go on to be cemented as X-Men cornerstones, with his run on the series being considered by some as the highpoint of the title. At Baltimore this year, Simonson recounted the story in her own words.

"[Byrne's exit was] right after I started," she said, "after this brilliant line of years worth of books. It was sort of my fault, because he and [legendary writer Chris Claremont] had a disagreement, and I agreed with Chris."

To be fair, perhaps Simonson taking all the credit for Byrne's exit is an oversimplification, especially as she explains she was sympathetic to his ultimate position.

"Really, it was," she continues, "I think John wanted control of a book, and he really deserved it. He wrote the stories and he wanted to do it all himself."

But at the same time, as any good editor would, Simonson knew what made the story tick.

"But the X-Men was really Chris's book," she says, "And so John went off and did Fantastic Four. It was really great and it sold really, really well."

A pretty happy ending to a dispute, especially for fans of Byrne's lauded Fantastic Four run and his later She-Hulk work. For Simonson at that moment, though, things were looking pretty bleak.

"I'm stuck trying to figure out, 'Oh God,' what do we do now?" she concludes, "I thought I killed it. I had this brilliant, brilliant book that I just love and I've put an arrow in its heart. It's gone."

As we all know, Simonson's work on the X-Men didn't just not kill the book, but brought it and its spinoff New Mutants (which Simonson pioneered) into a whole new era of comics to be beloved by even more fans. Ultimately, we'd say her arrow didn't much wound the X-Men comics, and even if it did, well... the X-Men have a thing about coming back to life.

Join Popverse in our own little X-Mansion as we cover just about everything you need to know about the X-Men. Learn how Marvel's mighty mutants are classified by power, or why the Krakoan Age of comics is coming to an end. And once you're done with those, keep up with the characters' big screen outings via Popverse's X-men movie watch order.